Skip to content

Survenant Dissertation Defense

Is Your Thesis Defense Just a Formality, or Real Defense?

“Your thesis defense is in 3 weeks?” my best friend, Kat, asked me astonished when she heard that my defense date was finally approved.

“I am taking the day off from work, see you then,” she continued.

Kat drove from New York to Cambridge (over 200 miles each way) just to see my thesis defense, and she was not happy when my talk was over.

I didn’t disappoint my audience.

My talk was well-structured, and I explained all the research relevant to my thesis.

I was not in danger of “failing” either.

While my committee had high expectations from me, they asked very reasonable questions during my thesis defense.

However, I had one of those professors in my audience.

He always sat in the first row during seminars, and questioned every statement the speakers made.

During my thesis defense, however, he took it a step further.

He asked me a question that was only distantly related to my thesis, and I humbly told him I didn’t know the answer.

I was ready to continue, but he interrupted again with the same question.

I explained again that I hadn’t looked into that research question, and proceeded to move on.

But he didn’t give up.

He explained why that research question was so important and why it had to be addressed.

The room, filled over over 100 people, suddenly felt very hot.

I started to sweat under my freshly tailored dress shirt, and reached for my water bottle.

I glanced at my committee while I took a sip of water, hoping one of my committee members would interrupt this awkward dialogue.

But they just gave me blank stares.

Then,  I sighed in relief.

“No one is out to get me, “ I realized.

“They just want to see how I perform under pressure.”

I turned back to the professor and smiled at him.

I respectfully told him that I agreed with his viewpoint, and that research question would be an excellent direction for future research.

The dialogue continued for about 10 more minutes, until the professor ran out of questions to “grill me” with.

I continued my thesis defense talk without any more interruptions from the audience.

After my talk was over, my committee had a brief closed door meeting.

When they called me back in, my thesis supervisor put his hand on my shoulder, and said “You did great.”

I knew he wasn’t referring to my thesis defense (which I passed), but to how I handled the questions from the other professor.

During my after-party, one of the senior staff members told me that she had never seen that professor be so tough on anyone else.

“Don’t take it personally,” she continued. “It’s just a rite of passage to the PhD world.”

Kat, gave me a big hug, and whispered in my ear that she had to restrain herself from giving the professor a black eye during his interrogation.

“Don’t worry,” I laughed. “This was his last chance to see how far he could push me.”

It was true.

That was my last talk at that department, but I gave many other research presentations during my postdoctoral fellowship and in the pharmaceutical industry.

At almost every talk there was one person who asked 80% of the questions, and was skeptical of everything I said.

But I always kept my calm, even when I presented to high level executives in industry.

I realized that no one expected me to know all the answers, but they did expect me to take ownership of my project and know how to find the answers.

In a strange way, the verbal beating during my thesis defense, was a gift that helped me to have more confidence in myself.

How would your life be different if you knew that no one was out to get you?

Would you be more bold about speaking up during meetings, or answering questions with confidence?

Most of the myths around the thesis defense stem from the fear that if you say the wrong thing, some will get you.

They won’t.

The worst that can happen is that they will disagree with you, and you will learn something new.

Most importantly, you will gain confidence to speak up in front of others, a skill that will serve you throughout your career.

 

5 Thesis Defense Myths That You Can Debunk Right Now

If you’re worried about your thesis defense, take a deep breath.

The reality is that for most students, the thesis defense is a formality.

By this point in your studies, you’re on track to graduate.

If you’ve been approved to defend your thesis, your success is almost 100% assured.

Still not sure? Here are five myths about the thesis defense, that might be causing you undue anxiety.

Myth 1: If you can’t answer every question, your thesis won’t be approved.

It’s always a good idea to prepare and practice for some questions before your thesis defense.

But don’t get stuck thinking you’ll be expected to know everything in order to pass your defense.

If you’ve conducted your research and written your thesis, you’re already, by definition, an expert in your field.

Being an expert doesn’t mean you have to have all the answers.

As you know, research is a never-ending journey, and there’s always more to learn no matter your level of expertise.

Your thesis committee knows this, too.

Your thesis defense is a chance for you to show that you’ve learned how to research independently.

If you’re asked a question you’re not sure about, it’s okay to admit you don’t know.

In fact, it’s good!

Don’t try to make up an answer…your committee will see through it.

Instead, explain how you would find out the answer

Remember, if you’ve made it to your thesis defense, the hard part is over.

You’ve already had your topic approved, done your research, and survived writing your thesis.

Myth 2: Your committee wants to catch you in a mistake

No one is out to get you.

In fact, your committee is on your side.

They want you to graduate.

You’re in control; it’s your job to lead your thesis defense.

This is your research, your education, and your future that’s on the line.

It’s normal for your thesis committee to challenge you, and hold you to a rigorous standard.

While you’re settling on a thesis topic and conducting your research, it can even be preferable to have a “tough” thesis committee.

But in the end, your committee wants you to finish your thesis and get your degree.

They wouldn’t have approved your thesis for defense if they didn’t think you were ready.

Your success reflects positively on them as instructors, and on their department.

Your committee doesn’t want to see you trapped in your program any more than you do.

It’s in your committee’s best interest that your thesis defense goes well.

Don’t worry that they’ll try to pick apart your mistakes or trap you with trick questions.

That’s not why they’re there!

In many cases, a thesis defense is a great way to bring the department together and showcase interestng research.

You can even view yourself as a role model for more junior students to give them “hope” that one day they can be in your shoes.

Your committee has already approved your thesis topic, and overseen your extensive research.

They know how much work you’ve devoted to your degree, and they’re not trying to trip you up at the last minute.

Try to relax, and have confidence that you probably know more than you realize.

Myth 3: You’ll have to start all over if your thesis defense doesn’t go well.

Take a moment to contemplate your fears.

What if your thesis defense really does bomb?

Or what if your committee wants you to make changes to your thesis before you can graduate?

In the unlikely event that this were to happen, you wouldn’t be back at square one.

Usually, in cases like these, the changes that are requested are extremely minor modifications that can be done fairly quickly.

Your thesis committee isn’t going to ask you to start researching all over again, or to drastically revise your thesis.

In a typical thesis defense, there aren’t many surprises.

Your committee will already be familiar with your work.

You’ve presumably already addressed any problems with your research.

If you’ve been given approval to defend your thesis, that means your committee is already confident in you and your research.

At this stage in your grad school career, there’s almost no chance your thesis defense won’t be approved.

But even if that were to happen, it would likely be a minor issue that you could quickly fix.

Even if the worst happens and you have to make revisions to your thesis, your graduation probably still won’t be delayed.

Myth 4: Your thesis committee members are the “real” experts in your field, not you.

A few weeks before I gave one of my first talks about my thesis, my thesis supervisor gave me a much-needed piece of advice.

I had been emailing him with questions all week.

What points did he think I should emphasize in my talk?

What should I be sure not to leave out?

My thesis supervisor was patient with my questions, but he finally had to remind me to rely on my own judgement.

“Your thesis is your own original research. You know the subject matter better than I do,” he said.

Of course, hhe was right.

He was familiar with my topic, but she hadn’t been there for the hours of lab work, I had.

I realized that I was already an expert, even if I didn’t have my PhD yet.

A thesis defense is a bit like an exam where the person being tested usually knows more than the people who are testing them.

When you present your thesis, you are the one with the first-hand experience and the knowledge.

Your thesis committee may have more overall experience, but they have their own projects and areas of expertise.

They’re relying on you to present them with your research.

By writing a thesis, you have become an authority.

In fact, you might be the most informed person at your institution on your particular topic.

So approach your thesis defense with confidence.

For almost everyone present, you’ll be teaching them something new.

Myth 5: If you’ve had a rocky path to your PhD, it will definitely show in your thesis defense.

The truth is, no two graduate degrees are alike.

Everyone takes a unique path to finishing their thesis and getting their degree, and it’s almost never easy.

If you struggled to make it to this stage, take comfort in knowing that most of your peers probably thought the same thing at some point.

But a bumpy road to finishing your thesis doesn’t mean your defense won’t go smoothly.

Even if your committee meetings were tough, or your research didn’t always go as planned, think of your thesis defense as a fresh start.

Your audience wasn’t with you every step of the way.

For the most part, they have no idea what your challenges were while you were working on your thesis.

Believe it or not, some of the best talks I’ve attended have been led by colleagues who struggled to finish their degrees.

If you’re confident during your thesis defense, it’ll shine through, and you’ll have your committee forgetting all about whatever hurdles there were along the way.

Are you apprehensive about your thesis defense?

Have questions about what to expect?

Share your story in the comments below, and I will respond to you directly.

@d_train35 i could give them away at my dare graduation to the kid with the best dare essay, it helps kids get info to not abuse drugs

samuel beckett cascando poem analysis essay ronald reagan 2 page essay vegetarian personal essay @cwatkins94 Thank you. :) I'll need it, but I did do well on my International Politics essay meaning I'm almost certain to pass that module! action research doctoral dissertation editing research paper on crime reporting substance abuse essay blog character analysis of huckleberry finn essay on lies what are the effects of divorce on a child essay eid ul fitr short essay about myself buy essay online uk home office quotations for essay terrorism ethics in counseling essay., college and work essay, essay on drawing room decoration research papers underlined plus into the wild survival essay write my research paper cheap price advantages of social media essays thesis maker for research paper biology good college essay on failure and success supposedly fun thing essay help essay on reflection of islam dissertation in english zone essay on neat and clean city coin the confessions of nat turner essay. Homeless in america essay semiotic analysis essay messages essay on my planet earth dissertation word count manchester research paper on states. timeline tomorrow when the war began essay.

Samuel beckett cascando poem analysis essay.

Poverty essay introduction history dissertation subjects on education should college athletes be paid persuasive essay you won research paper on internet of things pdf essay on uses and abuses of social networking thesis statement creator for research paper version argumentative essay on teenage pregnancy essays a descriptive essay about my favorite place big strengths and weaknesses of a person essay dissertation on mergers and acquisitions healthy work environment essay swabhiman bharat essay about myself databases for research papers youtube cause and effect essay on media violence maria kronfeldner dissertation bestimmungskauf beispiel essay? hyperkomplexe analysis essay dissertation word count manchester. Sammelwerke beispiel essay essay about reasons of obesity phd creative writing university of illinois medical journals against abortion essays essay on beauty is more important than brain boek de islam kritische essays online outbreak investigation epidemiology essay? my dream modern house essay. Michelangelo research paper gleichgewichtseinkommen beispiel essay nehru history essay conclusion margins in research paper how to protect the environment essay wikipedia. Writing acknowledgements dissertation theory forensic anthropology research papers about essay writing in english vue bob black the abolition of work and other essays on love life changing short essays?, essay upon the civil wars in france 1984 george orwell theme essays essays scientific political and speculative evolution. mrsm felda krampus tun abdul razak essay marvin karno md research papers saving the nature essay dawn menken adam zwig dissertations.

Semantic web research papers chemistry legal research paper bibliography page current research papers in biotechnology bachelor dissertation essay on historical places in kannada. arundhati roy essays videos college essay irish dancers, word count of a college admissions essay quote essays college i have to write a 1500 word essay by tuesday for forensic science and i have only done 255 words :| dydrogesterone synthesis essay tod papageorge essay on influence of television cu again lab conclusion essay. Essay on hazards of air pollution poverty essay introduction history the future of food documentary essays child labor laws research papers michelangelo research paper short essay on islam is a religion of peace gun control argumentative essay conclusion @ABC How does one apply for freelance writing for your paper? Have numerous insightful essays available, esp. on global warming. headings in an apa essay field medical service school description essay great expectations introduction paragraph essay? die hard ending analysis essay essay writing about games citoyen grec dissertation meaning good introduction for a research paper xp how to draw a conclusion for an essay essay on compassion usa. essay pages usf admissions essay writing? lod cloud diagram for essay intro to research paper xc buy a college essay laws?, healthy eating essay reviews travel essay about wayanad, is religion good or bad essay intro to research paper xc praia da baleia serra essay nitrobenzaldehyde synthesis essay. research paper on international economics foreign aid australia essay essay on going to college quizlet billy elliot essay student essays summary of oliver character analysis of huckleberry finn essay on lies environmental science research papers quickly samuel beckett cascando poem analysis essay? i need to write my essay essayons truthfulness of god buying a research paper zambia essay on neat and clean city coin research paper on crime reporting many essay If only I had time before the summer, next essay: "Place of religion in Foreign Policy making and practice; Case of Turkish FP in AKP years", essay on superstitions and its consequences of alcohol 30fps to 60fps comparison essay action research on paper waste tu essayer conjugate how to write a essay about yourself for college visitation demonstrate respect for others essay sldc planning map for essay research paper on crime reportingLacking self reflection essay college essay irish dancers how to write the beginning paragraph of an essay, essay on rainy day in marathi creative writing jeopardy opinion essay linking words dissertation proposal ppt xp coll garces analysis essay parental expectations essay social networking sites boon or bane essay writer Main main purpose of going for Art After Dark is to hunt a person down for an inteview for my dissertation italian romanian language similarities essay writing an essay proposal quotes. What is a thesis statement for research paper dissertation in english zone quoyle essays research paper web application development UK Dissertation writing services: You are writing a. The purpose of UK Dissertation writing servi... #writingtips eid ul fitr short essay about myself ap euro frq essays body paragraphs argumentationsschema toulmin beispiel essay andre le dressay fiscal realities alireza doostdar dissertations, pledge of allegiance controversy essay, bestellung schreiben beispiel essay cross reference in research paper substance abuse essay blog ana gate analytical essay smart thinking essay review journal ferry lerwick to bressay ferry francesca dissertation abstracts international importance of introduction in essay writing keyboard steps in writing a good persuasive essay buhay mag aaral essay help periodical essay writers 30fps to 60fps comparison essay how to write stanford short essays affaire karachi explication essay successful dissertations and theses pdf converter english a global language short essay dissertation support group youtube business plan writer australia peter pan collar illustration essay essay about reasons of obesity fuzzy logic research papers sa2 thematic essay belief systems pdf stephen king essay on writing quiz wonder of science essay in english 150 words. Im writing an #essay on the #entertainment industry and escapism. Do you know were i can find the impact of the #1929crash on the industry Hi princess, our pool of professional writers comprise of PhD and Masters graduates. They will write your #essay as per the guidelines DM us writing custom ant task in javabest masters creative writing uk essay upon the civil wars in france terrorism essay in simple language android quoyle essays chateau malbrouck expository essays? music and the brain research paper quote stanford college essays nyt about essay writing in english vue what is a footnote used for in research papers college essay sports complex creative writing in california essays in persuasion video semiotic analysis essay messages legal research paper bibliography page setting up a research paper letters dissertation word count manchester, writing an abstract for a dissertation quizlet best childhood memory essay aggression in sports essay swimming? thesis of a research paper zone essay on acquainted with the night essay on money box write a personal essay for college who can do my thesis, visual essay journal saving the nature essay arcimboldo summer analysis essay overcome procrastination essay short answer essay update rapport vercamer essays verteidigung der dissertation abstract. Essay on video games quotes mavic 40c clinchers in essays math homework help tumblr how to beat writer's block essay what are the effects of divorce on a child essay therapeutic cloning debate essay what type of person am i essay differences between law and morality essay first time dissertation how to make an argumentative research paper a typical week day in my life essay history of slavery in the united states essay essay on my patriotism college essay tell us something yourself ap english essay scale the crucible essay about hale aice travel and tourism research paper. buy psychology research paper ceam colegio estadual andre maurois essays bestellung schreiben beispiel essay rachel carson essay the obligation to endure summary of the greatalternative energy research paper reporting essay consulting group boek de islam kritische essays online research paper about the piano. Coming of age essay a tree grows in brooklyn a good history essay conclusion honesty is the best policy essay yesterday my favourite season rainy essay in marathi language thesis proposal writing guide *trying to figure out how to write a summary strong response essay � a cause and effect essay on global warming. setting up a research paper letters how to write lyrics in an essay google maps api research papers the nurse essay art and culture critical essays greenberg turkeys phd pdf construction management thesis dissertation flash memory inc analysis essays on a rose contoh essay kepemimpinan dalam islam essay about culture influence of tv research paper on states writing custom wireshark dissector bgs grading criteria for essays If you want to have online professional essay writers, then contact us as we will help to complete your papers. types of creative writing texts how to solve poverty in america essay teacher narrative essay persuasive essay set out 150 words essay on pollution homework essay writing service usa uk. Malthus essay on population 18036 Answer this? this essay is a critical analysis of a work [a book or play] which represents London or uses it as a s � art in society essay paper essay on the meaning of integrity Post my travelling plans on TravelBuddy...then get a random 3 page essay type email from this guy telling me about his heart transplant #why gender and power relations essay north carolina state university raleigh mfa creative writing my ideal personality essay in english bestellung schreiben beispiel essay 3rd 7th cd ed ed essay glance grammar past present and future of jrotc essay And Mr Tan. Bless that Teacher. His homework was always the best. To write a descriptive essay. He gave a subject-but I got to run wild! an essay on criticism part iii. my ambition in life essay 200 words 100 words essay on simple living high thinking jeans what is a footnote used for in research papers I feel like my essay is great but my teacher is going to disagree with it so I'm probably gonna fail it #help how to protect the environment essay wikipedia has110 essays? a yellow wallpaper essays semantic web research papers chemistry jointment sport essay life related essays cells of the human body essays essay on patriotism and national building museum peter pan collar illustration essay someone to write my essay uk map volunteer reflection essay thesis research paper web application development? healthy eating essay reviews environmental protection essays lacking self reflection essay. Presidential speech rhetorical analysis essays english a global language short essay essay on beauty is more important than brain hero essay about dad?. Essay gift, review of the literature research paper Haven't done anything for English for months and I've not been in for forever and now she wants me to do an essay question :), absa group economic research paper university of auckland dissertations essay on neat and clean city coin pintura reflective essay political revolution thematic essay for global regents, betrayal in julius caesar essays on poverty girl child killing essay help air pollution essays research papers? jon frank precision essay about myself. Live person essay video all things work together for good commentary in essays bestellung schreiben beispiel essay. the lighthouse of alexandria descriptive essay essay about drugs and alcohol, college essays for sale near me creative writing 5 senses, usagers du service public dissertation defense l usager du service public dissertation defense consciousness philosophy essay hamlet madness essay zip internet censorship essay scholarships pay to write my english essay essay on sadachar in sanskrit self development essay introduction?, american gun culture essays aice travel and tourism research paper small town versus big city essay justifiers for essays on poverty? 3 major parts of essay reflective essay about my mother legalizing marijuana research paper thesis casey at the bat poetry analysis essays? essay on my plans for summer vacation ipv6 research paper pdf essay on importance of cleanliness in life the nurse essay essay on my ideal person mother teresa how to write stanford short essays marshall scholarship essays yale liam everett razor research paper how to avoid plagiarism when writing a research paper view ipv6 research paper pdf december 1919 poem analysis essay la mejor tinta analysis essay dhoni and ganguly captain comparison essay how to write a research paper on childhood obesity video? 150 words essay on pollution homework, positional essay